The Obama Doctrine


The problem with Obama’s Middle East policy is that there is no policy, and that’s why we have heard nothing consistent or comprehensive from the administration that would try to explain our glee at Mubarak and Ali leaving but outreach to the far worse Assad, the monster Ahmadinejad’s enjoying exemption from “meddling” but Qaddafi’s being merely “unacceptable,” talk of going into Libya as good but no talk of Saudi Arabia going into Bahrain as good or bad, reset diplomacy as not judging other regimes but human rights declared universal, no idea whether plebiscites without constitutional guarantees will bring governments worse than the pro-American autocracies that fall, and loud declarations of Bush’s policies as bad but also reset diplomacy’s quietly embracing most of them in Afghanistan, Iraq, and the not-to-be-named war on terror.

All this is in line with simultaneously establishing withdrawal dates and surging into Afghanistan, virtually closing Guantanamo, and regretting Iraq while claiming it as a possible “greatest achievement.” All that can be said for it is that the chaos keeps our friends and enemies guessing — and that confused inaction is, I suppose, preferable to confused intervention.

What then is or was at the heart of U.S. bewilderment in the region?

Three flawed assumptions:

1) Not being George Bush meant that we should keep mum about “democracy” and “human rights” and not judge the culturally constructed practices of ‘other’ indigenous governments. We saw that rhetoric early in 2009, and it was reified by our silence over the Iranian protests six months later. Oddly, we were to assume that a right-wing Bush had been too idealistic, and that a left-wing Obama was going to return to realpolitik dressed up in multicultural platitudes of non-intervention. The result is that we have become loud multicultural neocons who sermonize but are not taken too seriously;

Read more

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

I can hardly wait for Katie Couric to ask some presidential hopeful, “What do you think about the Obama doctrine?”

The OBAMA DOCTRINE?? um, uh.. Basketball… um GOLF… um, take lots of trips.. uh, bow and apologize a lot… um, HIDE when things go bad, then say something lame and immaterial….then go away and hope it blows over fast so i don’t have to make a decision.. um, “where’s the Teleprompter”?? Make a DECISION?? NOW!?!?!? Um, Michelle! where did you put my “Magic 8-Ball?????
God help us, 2012 cannot come FAST ENOUGH!