An early setback for the ‘you didn’t build that’ defense

Spread the love

Loading

Hugh Hewitt @ The Washington Examiner:

“You didn’t build that.”

This was essentially Samsung’s defense to charges by Apple that the former had stolen the latter’s intellectual property. This defense didn’t work. It got blown out of the water.

An American jury sided with Apple Friday and found that Apple did indeed “build that.” Jurors blistered Samsung with a billion dollar verdict. The shape of the communications industry is thus set to proceed on the same rules of all of American industries through all of American history: Apple owns what Apple built in the past or builds in the future.

The biggest jury of all is the American electorate, as I argue in the opening pages of my new book, “The Brief Against Obama: The Rise, Fall and Epic Fail of the Hope and Change Presidency.” I begin the book by quoting my law partner Gary Wolensky — a very fine, extraordinarily successful trial lawyer who defends American companies against ruinous claims brought by the plaintiffs’ bar. Gary trusts jurors because fairness is drilled into every American from an early age, and thus facts — if well presented — win cases. A strong attachment to justice in matters of property and responsibility is walking around in every American. Gary likes to go to trial because he believes in juries.

It looks like we should be trusting the American voter as well. The polls are moving in the direction of Romney/Ryan, and a lot of that movement is because the president dropped his guard for a moment when he gave the “You didn’t build that” speech, and Mitt Romney won’t let it pass.

He shouldn’t, nor did he when he appeared on my radio show Friday afternoon. “Everywhere I go, people are saying look, I did build this,” Romney told me. “And the people who work in this enterprise built it. It was not built by government. It was built by free people. And you know, the president says we’re taking him out of context, but go look at the rest of the speech. The context is worse than the quote, because he somehow casts aspersions on people who are working hard to get smarter, and people who are just working hard. The reality is America is a nation which has been built by individuals pursuing their dreams. And whether that’s to get the honor roll or get a promotion, or open a business.”

Read more

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of

1 Comment
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

As published on the original site:

Is this article sort of a back hand admission that “you didn’t build that convention center”?